LeafFilter vs. LeafGuard: The Best Gutter Guards

A white gutter guard

If you have gutters, then you know the importance of keeping them clean. Leaves and debris can quickly clog up your gutters, causing water to back up and potentially damage your home. That’s why many homeowners choose to install gutter guards – to help keep their gutters clean and functioning properly. But with so many different types and brands of gutter guards on the market, how do you know which one is right for you? In this blog post, we’ll compare two popular brands – LeafFilter vs. LeafGuard – and discuss the differences between them. We’ll also provide reviews from actual homeowners, as well as pricing information to help you make an informed decision about which is the best gutter guard company for your needs.

How Do Gutter Guards Work?

Gutter guards work by covering the top of your gutters with a mesh, screen, or other type of material that allows water to flow through while preventing debris from entering the gutters. Some gutter guards are designed to fit over existing gutters, while others are built-in as part of your new gutter system.

Overview of LeafFilter and LeafGuard

LeafFilter and LeafGuard are two gutter guard companies that provide gutter protection systems designed to prevent leaves, debris, and other outdoor materials from clogging gutters and downspouts. While both companies provide similar products and services, there are some notable differences between the two.

LeafFilter is a company that has been providing quality gutter guard systems for more than 15 years. The company’s main product is its patented LeafFilter Gutter Protection System, a stainless steel micro mesh screen that is installed over existing gutters to prevent debris from entering, and allowing water to flow freely. The company offers a lifetime warranty on its product and even claims that it can handle up to 60 gallons of water per minute. LeafFilter also provides installation services and offers financing options for customers.

LeafGuard, on the other hand, has been in the business for over 25 years and offers a similar product to LeafFilter. Its flagship product is the LeafGuard Gutter System, which is a one-piece gutter system that is custom-fit to each home. The system features a curved design that allows water to flow freely while preventing leaves and other debris from entering. The company offers a lifetime warranty on its product and claims that it can handle up to 32 inches of rain per hour. LeafGuard also provides installation services and offers financing options for customers.

LeafFilter and LeafGuard provide similar products and services designed to protect gutters and downspouts from debris. While there are some differences in the design of their products and the specific features they offer, both companies have a strong reputation for quality and customer satisfaction.

LeafGuard vs. LeafFilter Features

Here is a detailed explanation of LeafGuard’s services and features:

Design

LeafGuard is a one-piece, seamless gutter system that is custom-fit to your home. It is made of aluminum and has a curved hood that covers the gutter, allowing water to flow freely while keeping out debris. LeafGuard gutters have a built-in downspout that eliminates clogs and can handle up to 32 inches of rainfall per hour.

LeafFilter is a micro-mesh gutter guard that is made of surgical-grade stainless steel. It is installed on top of your existing gutters and has a 50-micron mesh that keeps out even the smallest debris. The mesh is not visible from the ground and can handle up to 60 gallons of water per minute.

Material

Leaffilter is made of surgical-grade stainless steel, which is a highly durable and long-lasting material that is resistant to rust, corrosion, and UV radiation. Stainless steel is also easy to clean and maintain, making it an ideal material for gutter protection systems. Leaffilter’s micromesh design features tiny holes that allow water to flow through while keeping out even the smallest debris like pine needles, shingle grit, and insect nests. The frames and supports are also made of uPVC, a strong and durable plastic that is resistant to corrosion and weathering.

Leafguard is made of aluminum, which is a lightweight, strong, and rust-resistant material. Aluminum is also a popular choice for gutters because it’s relatively easy to shape and install. The Leafguard system consists of a one-piece gutter and hood design that is custom-fit to your home’s dimensions. The hood is curved and designed to redirect water flow into the gutter while keeping out debris. The system also uses heavy-duty hangers and brackets to provide additional support.

LeafGuard vs. LeafFilter Pricing and Costs:

Here is a detailed comparison of pricing and costs for LeafGuard and LeafFilter:

  • Cost of Materials: Both LeafGuard and LeafFilter use high-quality materials that are durable and long-lasting. However, LeafGuard uses a patented one-piece gutter system, while LeafFilter uses a micro-mesh screen. The cost of the materials used by LeafGuard is generally higher than that of LeafFilter, but it is reflected in the quality and effectiveness of the product.
  • Cost of Installation: LeafGuard and LeafFilter require professional installation. The cost of installation for both products will vary depending on the size of your home and the complexity of the installation. However, the cost of installation for LeafGuard is typically higher than that of LeafFilter, due to the one-piece design and the specialized equipment and training required for installation.
  • Maintenance and Repair Costs: LeafGuard and LeafFilter both require minimal maintenance and repairs over the years. However, LeafGuard’s one-piece design makes it easier to maintain and repair, as there are no seams or joints that can become clogged or damaged over time. LeafFilter’s micromesh screen may require more expenses for maintenance, such as cleaning, to ensure that it is working effectively.

Other factors that affect the cost of gutter guard installation

  • Type of Gutter Guard: The type of gutter guard you choose will affect the cost of installation. There are different types of gutter guards available, including mesh screens, foam inserts, and solid covers. The cost of each type of gutter guard can vary, with solid covers generally being the most expensive.
  • Home Size: The size of your home will affect the cost of gutter guard installation. A larger home will require more materials and labor, which will increase the cost of installation. Similarly, homes with more complex rooflines may be more difficult to install gutter guards on, which may also increase the cost.
  • Gutter Condition: If your gutters are damaged or in poor condition, you may need to repair or replace them before installing gutter guards. This can add to the overall cost of installation.
  • Accessibility: The accessibility of your gutters can also affect the cost of installation. If your gutters are difficult to access or require special equipment or safety measures to install gutter guards, this can increase the overall cost.
  • Local Labor Costs: The cost of labor for gutter guard installation can vary depending on your location. Labor costs may be higher in areas with a high cost of living or where specialized skills are required.
  • Additional Features: Some gutter guard systems may include additional features, such as built-in heating systems to prevent ice dams, or systems that divert rainwater to a rain barrel. These additional features will increase the overall cost of installation.
  • Contractor Fees: The cost of gutter guard installation will also include any fees charged by the contractor or installation company. These fees can vary depending on the company and the scope of the project.

LeafGuard vs. LeafFilter Installation Process

The installation processes for LeafGuard and LeafFilter are similar in some respects, but differ in others due to the unique design of each product. Here’s a detailed overview of the installation processes for LeafGuard and LeafFilter:

LeafGuard Installation Process

  • Inspection: A LeafGuard representative will visit your home to assess the roofline and gutters and to provide an estimate of the project cost.
  • Gutter Removal: If you have existing gutters, they will be removed to make way for the LeafGuard gutter system.
  • Custom Fabrication: LeafGuard gutters are custom-fabricated on site to fit the exact measurements of your home. This process typically involves using a roll-forming machine to create the seamless one-piece design of the gutters.
  • Installation: Once the gutters have been fabricated, they are installed onto your home’s roofline. The LeafGuard system includes a built-in hood that prevents debris from entering the gutters, and a downspout that directs rainwater away from your home’s foundation.
  • Clean Up: Once the installation is complete, the installers will clean up any debris and haul away the old gutters.

LeafFilter Installation Process

  • Inspection: A LeafFilter representative will visit your home to assess the roofline and gutters and to provide an estimate of the project cost.
  • Gutter Cleaning: Before installation, the existing gutters will be thoroughly cleaned to remove any debris or buildup.
  • Micromesh Installation: The LeafFilter system includes a micromesh screen that fits over the top of the gutters to prevent debris from entering. The micromesh is installed onto the existing gutters using brackets and screws.
  • Sealing: Once the micromesh is installed, any gaps or joints are sealed with a specialized sealant to prevent leaks or water damage.
  • Testing: The installers will test the LeafFilter system to ensure that it is functioning properly and that water is flowing smoothly through the gutters.
  • Clean Up: Once the installation is complete, the installers will clean up any debris and haul away any old gutter guards or screens.

Differences in the installation processes of the two brands

LeafGuard gutters are designed as a seamless, one-piece gutter system that is custom-fitted to your home. The installation process typically involves removing your old gutters and then installing the new LeafGuard gutters in their place. This may require some modifications to your roofline, depending on the specific design of your home. The installation is usually performed by a certified LeafGuard dealer who will ensure that the gutters are properly installed and functioning as intended.

LeafFilter gutter guards are installed directly onto your existing gutters. This means that there is no need to remove your old gutters, which can save time and money during the installation process. The installation process typically involves cleaning your gutters, fitting the LeafFilter guards onto your gutters, and then securing them in place. LeafFilter guards are designed to be installed by professionals, so the installation is typically performed by a certified LeafFilter dealer.

LeafGuard vs. LeafFilter Warranty

Here’s a comparison of the services and warranties offered by LeafGuard and LeafFilter:

LeafGuard Warranty

  1. No Clog Warranty: LeafGuard offers a “No Clog Warranty” for the lifetime of your home. This warranty guarantees that your gutters will never clog. If they do clog, LeafGuard will clean them for free.
  2. ScratchGuard Paint Finish Warranty: LeafGuard also offers a “ScratchGuard Paint Finish Warranty” that covers scratches and fading for 20 years. This warranty ensures that your gutters will look like new for many years to come.
  3. Clog-Free Guarantee Maintenance Program: LeafGuard offers a maintenance program that includes an annual inspection and cleaning of your gutters. This program ensures that your gutters are always working efficiently and effectively.
  4. Transferable Warranty: Both warranties are transferable to new homeowners, which can be a valuable selling point if you decide to sell your home.

LeafFilter Warranty

  1. Lifetime Warranty: LeafFilter offers a “Lifetime Warranty” that guarantees that your gutters will remain clog-free for the life of your home. If your gutters ever clog, LeafFilter will come out and clean them for free.
  2. Annual Maintenance: LeafFilter also offers an annual maintenance service to clean and inspect your gutters. This service ensures that your gutters are always working efficiently and effectively.
  3. Transferable Warranty: The warranty is transferable to new homeowners, which can be a valuable selling point if you decide to sell your home.

Advantages and disadvantages of professional installation versus DIY installation

When it comes to installing products like gutters, there are two main options: professional installation or DIY installation. Each method has its advantages and disadvantages, and it is important to consider these factors when deciding which option is right for you.

Advantages of Professional Installation

  1. Expertise: Professional installers are experts in their field, with years of experience and training. They know the best practices, materials, and techniques to use for your particular gutter installation.
  2. Time: Professional installation can save you time, as the installers will be able to complete the job quickly and efficiently, without any trial and error that a DIY installation might entail.
  3. Warranties: Most professional installations come with warranties that cover the workmanship and materials used. This provides peace of mind and protection against any problems that may arise.

Disadvantages of Professional Installation

  1. Cost: Professional installation can be more expensive than DIY installation, as you will need to pay for the installer’s time and expertise.
  2. Scheduling: You will need to schedule an appointment with the installer and work around their schedule, which can be inconvenient.

Advantages of DIY Installation:

  1. Cost: DIY installation can be less expensive than professional installation, as you will only need to pay for the materials.
  2. Control: With a DIY installation, you have complete control over the project, from start to finish.
  3. Flexibility: You can work on the project at your own pace and on your own schedule.

Disadvantages of DIY Installation:

  1. Expertise: If you don’t have experience with this type of installation, you may not know the best practices, materials, and techniques to use. This can lead to mistakes, which can be costly and time-consuming to fix.
  2. Time: DIY installation can take longer than professional installation, as you will need to learn the necessary skills and techniques, as well as work at a slower pace to ensure the quality of the installation.
  3. Warranties: If you make a mistake during the installation, it could void the warranty on the materials used, leaving you responsible for any problems that arise.

The decision between professional installation and DIY installation will depend on your personal preferences, skills, and budget. It is important to weigh the advantages and disadvantages of each option carefully and make an informed decision. If you’re unsure about your ability to handle a DIY installation, it may be worth investing in a professional gutter installation to ensure a quality job and to avoid any potential issues down the line.

Factors that Affect Gutter Guard Effectiveness

The effectiveness of gutter guards can vary depending on a few factors, including:

  1. Type of Gutter Guard: There are several types of gutter guards available, and some are more effective than others. For example, micro-mesh gutter guards are designed to prevent even the smallest debris from entering the gutters, while other types of gutter guards may be less effective at filtering out debris.
  2. Type of Debris: The type of debris that falls on your roof can also affect the effectiveness of gutter guards. Some types of debris, such as pine needles, can be more difficult to filter out than other types of debris.
  3. Roof Pitch: The pitch of your roof can also affect how well gutter guards work. If your roof has a steep pitch, it may be more difficult for debris to enter the gutters in the first place, reducing the need for gutter cleaning.
  4. Installation Quality: The quality of the installation can also affect the effectiveness of gutter guards. If the gutter guards are not installed correctly, they may not function as intended, allowing debris to enter the gutters.

Do Gutter Guards Eliminate the Need for Gutter Cleaning?

While gutter guards can reduce the amount of debris that enters your gutters, they may not eliminate the need for gutter cleaning entirely. Over time, debris can accumulate on top of the gutter guards, and this can lead to clogs and other issues. Additionally, some debris can still find its way into the gutters, especially if the gutter guards are not installed correctly.

It’s also worth noting that even with gutter guards, your gutters can still become dirty and stained over time, and this can affect the appearance of your home. For this reason, it’s a good idea to have your gutters cleaned and maintained on a regular basis, even if you have gutter guards installed.

Leafguard vs. Leaffilter Reviews

In terms of customer service and support, both companies have received generally positive reviews from customers. LeafFilter has an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau and has been named a “Top Performer” by a leading consumer magazine. LeafGuard also has an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau and has been recognized as a “Reader’s Choice” by a prominent consumer publication.

Leafguard Reviews

“I’ve had Leafguard installed for a few years now, and I couldn’t be happier with the product. I used to have to clean my gutters several times a year, but with Leafguard, I haven’t had to clean them at all. The installation was quick, and the team was professional and courteous.” – John S.

“Leafguard is a great product! We had it installed a year ago, and it has completely eliminated our gutter cleaning needs. The product is well-made, and we haven’t had any issues with it. I would highly recommend Leafguard to anyone who wants to save time and money on gutter cleaning.” – Amanda R.

“We had Leafguard installed last fall, and it has been a game-changer for us. We used to dread the fall season, knowing that we would have to clean our gutters multiple times. With Leafguard, we haven’t had to worry about it at all. The product is high-quality, and the customer service is excellent.” – David P.

Leaffilter Reviews

“I had Leaffilter installed a few months ago, and so far, it’s been great. The product does what it’s supposed to do and has kept all the debris out of my gutters. The installation process was quick, and the team was professional and friendly. I would recommend Leaffilter to anyone who wants to save time and hassle on gutter cleaning.” – Lisa M.

“Leaffilter is a great product! It’s been almost a year since we had it installed, and we haven’t had to clean our gutters at all. The product is well-made and has held up well through all kinds of weather. The team that installed it was knowledgeable and professional, and we’re very happy with the results.” – Steve K.

“We had Leaffilter installed on our home a few years ago, and it has been a fantastic investment. We used to have to clean our gutters multiple times a year, but now we don’t have to worry about it at all. The product is high-quality, and the customer service is excellent. I would highly recommend Leaffilter to anyone who wants to save time and money on gutter cleaning.” – Jessica T.

Conclusion

Gutter guards can be a useful tool for reducing debris accumulation in gutters and eliminating the need for frequent gutter cleaning. While they may not eliminate the need entirely, they can still save a lot of time and hassle when it comes to maintaining your gutters. Leafguard and Leaffilter are two popular brands that offer high-quality products with professional installation services. Their customers have reported positive results, so these brands may be worth considering if you’re looking for a reliable gutter guard system.